It may be bad of my to post a picture of something that is discontinued.
But I wanted to rave about a type of product that would work amazingly for paler gals. Liquid liner for a pale complexion that won't look like a harsh liquid black liner? Well, it's easy - go for a bronze. A brown base and some sparkles will make it looking soft on your eyes. In the pictures, you can see I'm not wearing any other make-up at all.
It looks best over paler and matte or satin shades. It can be worn over shimmers but you don't get much definition that way.
The product I used was Catrice, now discontinued, liquid liner in 040 Go, Get Bronzed.
I'm sure you can find a dupe.
I'm not too crazy about liner in general because I have small eyes and very pale skin. If you are the same, this is the type of color I suggest to you.
Hope it helps in any way,